How to avoid the customer service trap

Posted on: 14 December 2022

Many companies are stuck in the mindset that the only way to provide good customer service is by saying ‘yes’ to everything. But offering too much flexibility is costly and could restrict your ability to grow. Here’s how to operate more effectively and profitably while at the same time giving your customers the service they expect.

Production Planning Manufacturing Environment

We’ve recently worked with three companies that shared a common problem. While experiencing strong growth, all three were caught in what we call the customer service trap.

Like many businesses, these companies built their success on always being there for their customers – jumping through hoops to fill last-minute orders. Their customers love the attention and flexibility. However, a reactive approach to customer service doesn’t scale well.

“Production was just reacting to customer orders. Our customers liked the flexibility, but it wasn’t sustainable for us as a business.”

As the companies grew, so did the pressure on their manufacturing. With spare capacity gradually disappearing, last-minute orders were getting increasingly tricky to fill, requiring the constant adjustment of schedules. While some added more inventory to compensate for the demand uncertainty, they all struggled with delivery performance.

As one said, We were in the habit of just saying yes to every customer order. That’s fine when you have spare capacity, but we’re no longer in that situation”

Manufacturers in growth mode often see a squeeze on production capacity. This is only natural as companies want to ensure that future demand warrants investment in additional capacity. But the squeeze also highlights the need to reconsider how best to achieve good customer service.

This post covers a common misconception about customer service and how a change in mindset – and systems – can help prevent you from getting caught in the customer service trap.

Good customer service doesn’t mean saying yes to everything

Many companies are stuck in the mindset that the only way to provide good customer service is by saying ‘yes’ to everything. This is fine if you know that you can deliver, but often companies don’t know that with certainty, and end up scrambling to make it work.

Of course, every customer loves to feel like they’re your most important client, and they appreciate you for making their life easier. But what they like more than anything else – even more than knowing you are bending over backwards to keep them happy – is consistently receiving the right product at the right price at the exact moment they need it.

So how can you move out of fire-fighting mode and start operating more effectively and more profitably…while at the same time giving your customers the service they expect?

It all starts with an accurate forecast.

How to find your way to the win-win

At Optimity, we nearly always start with demand planning because it sets the pace for the rest of the supply chain. Implementing statistical and collaborative forecasting will improve your short- and long-term forecast accuracy. This allows you to get ahead of demand uncertainty and gain the forward visibility needed to effectively plan and operate your supply chain.

A statistical forecast provides a good baseline projection of demand for you and your customers. From here, demand collaboration tools enable the exchange of quantitative and qualitative forecast information, both within the company and with your customers. By involving your customers in your forecasting process, you can tap into their plans much sooner, benefiting both parties.

With a robust demand plan in place, the next step is to add production planning to the mix. An optimized production plan considers all costs and constraints, allowing planners to make more informed decisions and quickly respond to opportunities – regardless of the time horizon.

As one of these companies commented, “The solution allows us to see what we can deliver and when with our existing capacity – and, at what cost. We can now have a much better conversation with our customers. It completely changes the way we work.” 

This highlights how important it is to understand how changes in demand impact overall customer service and profitability.

Jeff Stites, CEO of ice cream maker Bubbies, gives another great example:
“A major retailer approached us with a significant opportunity. Once we added it into the system, we could see that it wouldn’t work. We wouldn’t be able to service the request and keep the product in stock. But because we had this information well in advance, our sales team was able to work with the customer and shift the order to a different time window. In the end, we could accommodate the new customer and everything else on our books.”

The outcome of this scenario could have been very different. Without knowing the impact of the order on the existing plan, the company would likely just have accepted the new business, inevitably causing a cascade of supply chain problems and ending up with at least one unhappy customer. If the company had declined, a great opportunity would have been lost.

(You can listen to Jeff’s interview with Lora Cecere of Supply Chain Insights here. Or read the Bubbies story here.)

Shift from being reactive to proactive

When you fall into the customer service trap, you risk jeopardizing your efficiency and profitability. What’s needed is a change in mindset – and software.

An integrated supply chain planning solution allows you to anticipate demand instead of simply reacting to customer orders. When you combine accurate forecasting with production and inventory optimization, you can service most of your last-minute orders from stock – without disrupting the production schedule. As a result, you no longer have to jump through hoops to keep your customers happy.

A modern planning solution lets you understand the full impact of demand on your supply chain – from both an operational and commercial perspective. Ultimately, you end up with a much better way of providing the excellent service both you and your customers deserve.

If you want to learn more about demand planning and supply chain optimization and how it could benefit your business, we’d love to talk.

Mark Walker

Mark Walker

Managing Director, North America

Mark is passionate about delivering real business value. He is highly skilled at cutting through complexity to help our customers evolve their businesses, processes and people for greater success.

CONTACT MARK

You might like

7 steps to better demand forecasting

A good demand plan provides the platform for a high-performance supply chain and guides both strategic decision making and financial planning. This post looks at seven critical considerations for demand planning success.
READ MORE
Supply Chain Insights Webinar with Jeff Stites CEO of Bubbies

Supply Chain Insights - Bubbies CEO, Jeff Stites on leadership and S&OP

Lora Cecere of Supply Chain Insights interviews Jeff Stites, CEO of Bubbies Ice Cream. He shares his personal experience in implementing S&OP and the role Optimity played in driving alignment across the business.
READ MORE

From Excel to excellence at Group of Butchers

Group of Butchers was growing fast. The business was thriving. But the rapid expansion also put pressure on the supply chain, and planning was becoming an issue. Group of Butchers turned to Supply Chain Company and Optimity for a solution.
READ MORE

Our website uses cookies to give you the best, most relevant experience. If you continue without changing your settings we’ll assume you are happy to receive cookies from our website.